The Lost Patrol: Flight 19, the Bermuda Triangle, and the Day Six Planes Vanished
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
On the afternoon of December 5, 1945, five U.S. Navy TBM Avenger torpedo bombers lifted off from Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale, Florida, on a routine overwater navigation training flight known as Navigation Problem No. 1. By nightfall, all five aircraft and their 14 crewmen had disappeared. Hours later, a PBM Mariner flying boat launched to search for them also vanished, taking 13 more men with it. In total, 27 men and six aircraft were lost in a single day, with no confirmed wreckage or bodies ever recovered despite one of the largest peacetime search efforts in history. The incident became the foundational story of the Bermuda Triangle legend.
The Mission
Flight 19 consisted of five Grumman/Eastern TBM Avengers, each typically carrying three crew (one plane flew with two after a crewman was excused). The flight leader was Lieutenant Charles Carroll Taylor, an experienced combat pilot and instructor who had flown in the Pacific. The students were mostly relatively inexperienced in overwater navigation on this specific route, though several had substantial flying hours.
The planned triangular route began with a flight east to Hen and Chickens Shoals (near the Bahamas) for practice bombing runs, continued farther east, turned north, and then returned southwest to Fort Lauderdale. The planes carried enough fuel for roughly four hours and were expected back before dark. Takeoff occurred at 14:10 local time after a slight delay.
They completed the bombing practice. Around 15:00, a pilot requested permission to drop his last bomb. Then the troubles began.
The Radio Calls and Growing Confusion
Around 15:40–16:00, radio operators and other aircraft began intercepting transmissions indicating the flight was lost. Lieutenant Robert F. Cox, another instructor airborne nearby (call sign FT-74), overheard the exchanges and made contact.
One student (identified as Powers) was asked for a compass reading and replied, in essence: “I don’t know where we are. We must have got lost after that last turn.”
Taylor (FT-28) then came on: “Both of my compasses are out, and I am trying to find Fort Lauderdale, Florida. I am over land but it’s broken. I am sure I’m in the Keys but I don’t know how far down and I don’t know how to get to Fort Lauderdale.”
This was a critical error. The Florida Keys lie well to the southwest. The flight had been operating over or near the Bahamas to the east. Taylor appears to have mistaken Bahamian islands for the Keys and concluded he was somewhere over or near the Gulf of Mexico rather than the Atlantic east of Florida.
Cox and base personnel advised him to put the sun on his port wing and fly north along the coast, or simply head west (the standard procedure taught at the station: if lost in the area, fly 270 degrees until you hit land). Taylor did not fully accept the advice. At one point he indicated he knew where he was and said something to the effect of “Don’t come after me.” He also refused or was unable to switch to the clearer search-and-rescue frequency, citing the need to keep his planes together on the training frequency (which suffered interference).
Subsequent transmissions showed continued confusion. Taylor directed headings that took the formation farther out, including suggestions to fly east. One voice in the flight was heard saying, in effect, “Dammit, if we could just fly west we would get home; head west, dammit.” The students largely stayed with their instructor.
Weather deteriorated as a frontal system moved through, bringing increasing cloud cover, wind, and rough seas. Sunset came around 17:30. By evening, fuel was critically low.
Around 18:20 (some accounts place the final clear transmission nearer 19:04), Taylor’s last widely reported message was heard: “All planes close up tight… we’ll have to ditch unless landfall… when the first plane drops below 10 gallons, we all go down together.”
After that, silence.
The Rescue Effort Disappears
As the situation became clear, the Navy diverted aircraft and alerted ships. Two Martin PBM Mariner flying boats were ordered into the search from NAS Banana River (now Patrick Space Force Base). One of them, PBM-5 Bureau Number 59225 (“Training 49”), launched at 19:27 with a crew of 13 under Lieutenant (jg) Walter G. Jeffrey. It made a routine radio call a few minutes later and was never heard from again.
Around 19:50, the merchant tanker SS Gaines Mills reported observing a burst of flames leaping roughly 100 feet high, burning for about ten minutes, at a position near 28°N 80°W. The ship later passed through an oil slick in the area and searched with lights but found no survivors. Radar contacts from a nearby Navy vessel were consistent with the Mariner disappearing at that time and place.
The Mariners were nicknamed “flying gas tanks” because of their large fuel loads and a known history of fuel-vapor accumulation and fires. The most accepted explanation for this loss is an in-flight explosion or fire.
The Massive Search and Official Findings
Beginning the next morning, the Navy mounted an enormous search involving hundreds of aircraft sorties and numerous surface vessels (including the escort carrier USS Solomons), covering more than 200,000–300,000 square miles of ocean and parts of Florida. Nothing definitive was found—no wreckage, life rafts, or confirmed debris from either Flight 19 or the Mariner.
A lengthy Board of Investigation convened. Its initial conclusions centered on navigational error by Taylor: he had become “uncertain as to in what position lay the Peninsula of Florida,” mistook the islands he saw for the Keys, and led the formation farther into the Atlantic instead of toward the coast. The board noted that some of the students appeared to have a better sense of their position. It attributed the Mariner’s loss to a probable mid-air explosion.
Taylor’s mother challenged the findings, arguing that without wreckage or bodies it was unfair to assign blame. In 1947 the Navy amended the official conclusion for Flight 19 to “causes or reasons unknown” and effectively exonerated Taylor of responsibility. The practical consensus among historians and investigators remains that the Avengers became disoriented, flew the wrong direction until fuel was exhausted, and ditched at night in rough seas. Avengers were heavy aircraft with limited ditching survivability; in high seas and darkness, any survivors would have had poor odds, and the planes would have sunk quickly.
No confirmed remains of the Flight 19 aircraft have ever been identified, despite various claims of wrecks over the decades that were later ruled out by serial numbers or other evidence.
The Legend and the Conspiracies
For nearly two decades the incident was treated primarily as a tragic navigation accident. In 1964, Vincent Gaddis published an article in Argosy magazine titled “The Deadly Bermuda Triangle,” using Flight 19 as a centerpiece and coining or popularizing the name for a roughly triangular region bounded by Florida, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico. Charles Berlitz’s 1974 bestseller The Bermuda Triangle amplified the story enormously, sometimes embellishing radio messages and weather conditions.
Popular accounts added dramatic flourishes not strongly supported (or absent) in the primary Navy records: phrases about “white water,” everything looking strange, or the ocean not looking right; claims of complete radio silence; and, most notoriously, versions of Taylor saying something like “Don’t come after me… they look like they are from outer space.” Larry Kusche and other researchers who examined the original transcripts and investigation files found that many of these elements were fabricated or heavily distorted by later writers.
Conspiracy and paranormal theories that attached themselves to the case include:
- Extraterrestrial intervention or abduction (famously depicted in Steven Spielberg’s Close Encounters of the Third Kind, where the Avengers reappear intact in the desert).
- Magnetic anomalies that scramble compasses (the region does have some magnetic variation, but not the extreme, unexplained effects claimed).
- Time warps, interdimensional portals, or vortices.
- Methane gas eruptions from the seafloor that could sink ships or disrupt aircraft (proposed as a general Bermuda Triangle explanation but not specifically evidenced here).
- Atlantis or ancient underwater technology.
- Government cover-ups or secret experimental technology.
Other, more mundane but still speculative ideas have included waterspouts, rogue waves, or sudden mechanical failures across the formation. None of these have supporting physical evidence.
A Measured View
The core documented facts are prosaic and tragic: an experienced instructor who became badly disoriented (possibly due to compass issues, fatigue, or a simple but catastrophic misidentification of islands), led his formation the wrong way in deteriorating weather, and ran out of fuel over open ocean at night. A search aircraft with a known vulnerability to fuel fires exploded. The lack of wreckage is not especially surprising given the depth of the water, the conditions, and the rapid sinking of the aircraft.
Statistical analyses of shipping and aviation traffic show that the Bermuda Triangle does not have a meaningfully higher rate of unexplained disappearances than other busy ocean regions once traffic volume is accounted for. Agencies such as the U.S. Coast Guard and NOAA have long treated the “mystery” as largely mythological.
Yet the complete absence of remains, the dual disappearance of the training flight and a rescue plane on the same day, the confused and increasingly desperate radio traffic, and the sheer scale of the fruitless search continue to give the story its lasting power. Flight 19 remains one of aviation’s most famous unsolved cases—not because the evidence points to the supernatural, but because the ocean kept its secrets.
Eighty years later, the men of Flight 19 and the crew of Training 49 are still listed as missing. Their story endures as a reminder of how quickly a routine training flight can turn catastrophic, and of how readily the human imagination fills the silence left behind.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment